The Rifle on the Wall :A Left Argument for Gun Rights

by Administrator 10. February 2013 01:52

The Fundamental Political Principle

"That rifle on the wall of the labourer's cottage or working class flat is the symbol of democracy. It is our job to see that it stays there."-- George Orwell1

Let’s start with this: The citizen’s right to possess firearms is a fundamental political right. The political principle at stake is quite simple: to deny the state the monopoly of armed force. This should perhaps be stated in the obverse: to empower the citizenry, to distribute the power of armed force among the citizenry as a whole. The history of arguments and struggles over this principle, throughout the world, is long and clear. Instituted in the context of a revolutionary struggle based on the most democratic concepts of its day, the Second Amendment of the United States Constitution is perhaps the clearest legal/constitutional expression of this principle, and as such, I think, is one of the most radical statutes in the world.

The question of gun rights is a political question, in the broad sense that it touches on the distribution of power in a polity. Thus, although it incorporates all these perfectly legitimate “sub-political” activities, it is not fundamentally about hunting, or collecting, or target practice; it is about empowering the citizen relative to the state. Denying the importance of, or even refusing to understand, this fundamental point of the Second Amendment right, and sneering at people who do, symptomizes a politics of paternalist statism – not (actually the opposite of) a politics of revolutionary liberation.

Read the rest of this excellent essay here:

http://www.thepolemicist.net/2013/01/the-rifle-on-wall-left-argument-for-gun.html

Tags:

Basic HTML supported

Add comment

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading

Blog Stats

Over 5 million page views since 2009.

Over 1.7 million unique visitors since 2009.

RecentComments

Comment RSS

News on Demand

Download OPML file OPML

Category list

None